Products 1-38 of 38
Show
Aged Asiago
Price: $6.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Stella Item #: 7580587489 -

A very hard, rich, sharp cheese with a slightly sweet fruity flavor

Aged Cheddar
Price: $6.75
View
Availability: In Stock
Kerrygold

Aged Cheddar is a pasteurized, grass-fed cow’s milk cheese that is aged for one year and undergoes a stringent grading process as it matures. Only the best-tasting cheese makes it through, resulting in a Cheddar that is rich and full-bodied with a smooth finish. Slice it up with warm apple pie or make it the hero of a wine and cheese pairing.Ingredients: Pasteurized milk, salt, cheese cultures and enzymes.

Blueberry Vanilla Chevre
Price: $5.75
View
Availability: In Stock
Montchevre

Sweetened with dried blueberries and flavored with vanilla, this cheese is perfect as part of a dessert course, or served with breakfast on a toasted bagel. Montchevre's fresh goat cheese logs are hand crafted from fresh prime quality milk. Each log is vacuum packed to lock in freshness and extend shelf life. Looks great on a cheese board when entertaining, or can be used to spread on toast or a bagel for breakfast.Made from pasteurized goat's milk.

Caraway Havarti
Price: $8.25
View
Availability: In Stock
Denmark’s Finest Item #: 9393668004 -

A whole cow’s milk cheese, smooth and buttery, flavored with caraway seeds

Colby Jack
Price: $6.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Tillamook Item #: 7283000550 -

This cheese is a mixture of colby and Monterey jack, with a gentle, savory flavor and a distinctive visual appeal

Cotswald
Price: $7.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Clawson Item #: 3500600044 -

A delicious blend of double Gloucester cheese with chopped onion and chives

Crottin Garlic and Herbs Goat Cheese
Price: $4.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Montchevre

Montchevré’s fresh goat milk Crottin are made with full respect for traditional French cheese-making techniques. These fresh goat cheeses are folded with high-quality ingredients to ensure rich, smooth texture and delicious flavors.

Dill Havarti
Price: $8.50
View
Availability: In Stock
Denmark’s Finest Item #: 9393668002 -

A whole cow’s milk cheese, smooth and buttery, flavored with dill

Enjoy Me With Chilled Beer Smoked Cheddar
Price: $8.25
View
Availability: In Stock
Somerdale

Enjoy me with Chilled Beer - Smoked Cheddar.Slightly crumbly with a wonderful smoked flavor, this cheddar is just the ticket with an IPA (India Pale Ale) or other amber beer.

Enjoy Me With Red Wine Vintage Cheddar
Price: $8.25
View
Availability: In Stock
Somerdale

Enjoy me with Red Wine - Vintage CheddarA beautifully aged vintage cheddar forming the perfect partner for a glass of Cabernet Sauvignon or Merlot.

Enjoy Me With White Wine Extra Sharp Cheddar
Price: $8.25
View
Availability: In Stock
Somerdale

Enjoy me with White Wine - Extra Sharp CheddarA robust and savory sharp cheddar, perfectly paired to enjoy with your favorite Sauvignon Blanc or Pinto Gris.

Extra Sharp Cheddar
Price: $6.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Tillamook

A sharp cheddar aged over 15 months to give it the most robust, complex cheddar flavor

Garlic Chili Pepper Cheddar
Price: $6.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Tillamook Item #: 7283000512 -

A delicious cheddar cheese with the kick of roasted garlic and red chili peppers

Garlic White Cheddar
Price: $6.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Tillamook Item #: 7283000520 -

A creamy white cheddar blended with the distinctive flavor of roasted garlic. For garlic lovers!

Hennings Two Tone Cheddar Cheese Curds
Price: $8.95
View
Availability: In Stock

A blend of white and colored cheddar cheese curds. Makes a great appetizer, snack, or addition to any party. Melt on pizza, make homemade mac & cheese, or enjoy on a salad. Freeze these curds to keep fresh, then microwave a few seconds to make them “squeak again”.

Hot Habanero Jack Cheese
Price: $6.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Tillamook Item #: 7283000514 -

A savory, mellow Monterey jack infused with the spice of habañero and jalapeño peppers for a fiery combination

Yanceys Hot Wasabi Horseradish
Price: $7.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Yancey's Item #: 1762 -

Yancey's Fancy Hot Wasabi Horseradish Cheddar.

Limburger
Price: $7.50
View
Availability: In Stock
Country Castle Item #: 283310101 -

A semi-soft, pungent smelling, surface ripened cheese

Medium Cheddar
Price: $6.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Tillamook Item #: 7283000101 -

A creamy, smooth cheddar aged over 60 days to develop its rich flavor

Medium White Cheddar
Price: $6.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Tillamook

Each day of the more than 60 days Tillamook Medium White Cheddar spends aging, makes it grow fuller and bolder in flavor. It does all this while maintaining the velvety-smooth texture and creaminess Tillamook's cheeses are known for, thanks to the high-quality, farm-fresh milk. It makes fruit swoon and wine sing.

Natural Montchevre
Price: $4.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Crottin Item #: 6165790331 -

A cheese mild in flavor with a rich and creamy texture

Oregon Blue Cheese
Price: $9.50
View
Availability: In Stock
Rogue Creamery Item #: 4117411040 -

Aged at least 90 days, this cheese is semi-soft, smooth and subtle in flavor, with richly hued blue-green veins.

Oregonzola Blue Cheese
Price: $10.25
View
Availability: In Stock
Rogue Creamery Item #: 4117412040 -

Aged at least 120 days, this veined cheese has a creamy, buttery texture.

Pepper Jack Cheese
Price: $6.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Tillamook

With its fresh taste, Tillamook's mild Monterey Jack is the perfect host for fiery bites of peppers. And just like all of their real cheese, it contains no artificial ingredients and is made with high-quality, farm-fresh milk.

Sharp Cheddar
Price: $6.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Tillamook Item #: 7283000102 -

A sharp cheddar aged for over 9 months to develop its full-bodied flavor that is a bit sharper than medium cheddar

Skellig Sweet Cheddar
Price: $7.05
View
Availability: In Stock
Kerrygold

Kerrygold Skellig is a creamy, full-flavored Cheddar imported from Ireland. As with all Kerrygold cheeses, Skellig is an all-natural cheese, produced with milk from grass-fed cows that graze on the green lush pastures of Ireland.Kerrygold Skellig is for the real cheese lover; it delivers exceptional flavor – rich and tangy, with a hint of sweetness. This cheese is crumbly, savory and has a lovely, butterscotch-like sweetness. Skellig is ideal for cooking, making cheese sauces or taking center...

Smoked Black Pepper White Cheddar
Price: $6.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Tillamook

Tillamook has taken creamy White Cheddar and peppered it with real hickory-smoked cracked black peppercorns. And the peppercorns aren’t the only real part. Tillamook's cheddar is made from four simple ingredients and aged naturally for a complex taste. Not only does the loaf look great in its peppercorn polka dots, it tastes great in them too. We think your party will agree.

Smoked Cheddar
Price: $7.00
View
Availability: In Stock
Apple Smoked Item #: 426200208 -

A cheddar cheese naturally smoked with apple and hardwood

Smoked Extra Sharp White Cheddar
Price: $6.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Tillamook

Like your cheese with a little smoke on it? We hear you. Like it even better with some age on it? We agree. In fact, we agree 18 months over. That’s the precise amount of time Tillamook's extra sharp white cheddar spends naturally aging before getting hardwood smoked. The result is a clean, rich cheddar taste with a mellow, smoky edge.

Smoked Gouda
Price: $6.25
View
Availability: In Stock
Dofino Item #: 3884640430 -

A smoked whole cow’s milk cheese

Smoked Gouda with Bacon
Price: $7.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Yancey's Item #: 1761 -

Yancey's Fancy Smoked Gouda with Bacon.

Smoked Gruyere
Price: $7.75
View
Availability: In Stock
Apple Smoked Item #: 426200308 -

A Gruyère cheese naturally smoked with apple and hardwood

Smoked Medium Cheddar
Price: $6.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Tillamook Item #: 7283000106 -

A delicious cheddar aged 60 days and infused with natural hardwood smoke for a distinctive flavor

Smoked Mozzerella
Price: $7.00
View
Availability: In Stock
Apple Smoked Item #: 426200408 -

A mozzarella cheese naturally smoked with apple and hardwood

Smoked Provolone
Price: $7.25
View
Availability: In Stock
Apple Smoked Item #: 426200508 -

A provolone cheese naturally smoked with apple and hardwood

Smokey Blue Cheese
Price: $9.50
View
Availability: In Stock
Rogue Creamery

A long, gentle cold-smoking over shells from Oregon hazelnuts infuses Rogue Creamery’s Smokey Blue cheese with an added layer of rich flavor and terroir. Sweet cream flavors and caramel notes balance earthy flavors of smoke and hints of roasted nuts. The result is a cakey yet smooth blue cheese reminiscent of candied bacon. Smokey Blue is the first of its kind in the world. Smokey Blue was inspired by a chef, and the flavor is signature to Oregon as the smoke is derived from Oregon hazelnut...

Yanceys Strawberry Chardonnay
Price: $7.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Yancey's Item #: 1763 -

Yancey's Fancy Strawberry Chardonnay Cheddar.

Vintage Extra Sharp White Cheddar
Price: $6.95
View
Availability: In Stock
Tillamook

This Vintage White Extra Sharp is made from the highest-quality milk with only two other ingredients. It's aged naturally for more than three years, making it Tillamook's oldest and wisest cheddar, and giving it a distinguished, refined, beautifully bold taste. It’s perfect for palates that love the complex taste of aged cheddar.